Cody posted his critiques in the comments of the entries, which is ok, but I'm copying them into this thread for easy reference.
Resemblance: 8 points, very accurate, although the head isn't the greatest.
Flow: 9 points, the most organic looking I've seen.
Creativity: 5 points, I like the hats and the minifig legs for arms.
Originality: 4 points, the methods you used are original, but the scale is typical for you.
Presentation: 5 points, good pictures.
Resemblance: 6 points, the shape isn't the best, but it was still recognizable.
Flow: 7 points, not the most organic look, but it is a very clean build.
Creativity: 4 points, the build uses kind of a lot of bricks and not too many specialty parts. Originality: 4 points, one other MOC was made at this scale
Presentation: 5 points, all the pictures were clear.
Resemblance: 5 points, easily recognizable.
Flow: 5 points, a little blocky for my taste.
Creativity: 4 points, nice feet.
Originality: 5 points, unique scale.
Presentation: 4 points, I would have liked to see a rear shot.
Resemblance: 9 points, very accurate.
Flow: 5 points, some SNOT work would make it look a lot more organic.
Creativity: 5 points, very nice.
Originality: 5 points, your style of building is very different, I like it!
Presentation: 5 points, clear pics.
Resemblance: 9 points, I could easily tell what pokemon it was
Flow: 5 points, a little too many studs for me, and a bit boxy
Creativity: 4 points, the minifig pouch really did something for me
Originality: 4 points, again with the minifig, and larger scale
Presentation: 3 points, Some pictures were good, but others were not as focused
Total: 25 points
Resemblance: 10, easily recognizable
Flow: 6 points, a little boxy, but I guess that is your building style
Creativity: 4 points, the baby really took the cake on that category
Originality: 3 points, original in scale, but not many interesting parts
Presentation: 4 points, very clean and polished photos, and a good variety
Total: 27 points
Resemblance: 8 points, because of the scale, it is a little tough to tell it is actually Kangaskhan
Flow: 9 points, incredibly smooth all over, very well put together
Creativity: 5 points, the burglar hat and archer hats are fantastic
Originality: 4 points, another builder built the same scale
Presentation: 5 points, great pictures
Total: 31 points
Resemblance: 6 points, it is kind of tough to tell what pokemon this is
Flow: 8 points, although there are a couple of studs, it worked for me
Creativity: 3 points, tough category
Originality: 4 points, same as Tracy
Presentation: 5 points, very clear photos
Total: 26 points Permalink
Okay, I hate to cut this off without a third judge, but I'm going to have to.
4th - Matt with 48 points
3rd - Brick Builder with 52
2nd - Filip with 56 points
1st - Tracy (yay) with 62 points
Great builds, all! I'm glad to say the club is alive and well. I just wish the effort I'm seeing in the entries was also present in the judging. I know judging's not the most fun thing, but we really need people to do it.
SPEAKING OF WHICH, I know I'm a freaking hypocrite for telling you guys to get with it and judge because I NEVER JUDGED THE HITMONTOPS. My shame is deep. I will do this tomorrow and that winner will finally be announced. Permalink