MOCpages : Share your LEGO® creations
LEGO models my own creation MOCpages toys shop The Car Builder's Club: contest groupVehicles
Welcome to the world's greatest LEGO fan community!
Explore cool creations, share your own, and have lots of fun together.  ~  It's all free!
Conversation »
Contest 2 Judging
Join to comment
 Group admin 
Here we put your judging of the second contest's entrees:
(entrees so far)
Senator Chincilla's Toyota FJ40 http://www.mocpages.com/moc.php/363327
Hank Erchief's 1983 K5 Blazer http://www.mocpages.com/moc.php/363330
Alex B's Off Roader of The future http://www.mocpages.com/moc.php/363227
Alexander Paschoaletto's Subaru Impreza WRX STI http://www.mocpages.com/moc.php/363500
Karol J's Military Half Track W/ power functions http://www.mocpages.com/moc.php/363525

Judging will use this criteria:

(MOC name here)
Exterior Shaping: /15
Exterior Details: /15
Interior Details: /5
Engine Details: /5
Functions: /10

Total: /50

Notes: (Judges can add any notes on the MOC they like here)


For MOCS 6 studs wide and under:
Exterior details: /25
Exterior Shaping: /25

(if not a perfect score, you can add 1 extra point each if it has interior, engine, or functions)

Total: /50

-----
Please try to consider the scale while judging. Thank you! :-)

-----
Please judge them in the same order posted above, also please put them in the same comment, you can later edit your comment so that it has the next entree, and the next.
when you've done all the entrees, place DONE on the bottom.

This will make it easier for me to combine the scores, and put out the results. Thank You.
Permalink
| June 28, 2013, 3:22 pm
 Group moderator 
Toyota Fj40 Trial Truck by: Senator Chinchilla

Exterior Shaping: 13/15
Exterior Details: 12/15
Interior Details: 2,5/5
Engine Details: 0/5 (there is no pics, and/or no videos of it)
Functions: 7/10

Total: 34,5/50


1983 k5 blazer by: hank erchief

Exterior Shaping: 7/15
Exterior Details: 6/15
Interior Details: 3/5
Engine Details: 3,5/5
Functions: 4/10 (I really like the suspention, but there is nothing else... :/ no openable doors, truck bed, ect)

Total: 23,5/50


Off Roader of the Future! by: Alex B

Exterior Shaping: 22/25
Exterior Details: 21/25 (a rear bumper could be a + I think! ; ) And, btw, why handcuffs under the truck? )
+1 for the suspention!

Total: 44/50

Note: I propose TLNA to "disperse" 'Interior Details', and 'Engine détails' judging points in others categories for "too small" creations! ; ), what do think about that? : )
ps: it's not what've done, yet! ; ) )


2007 Subaru Impreza WRX STI by: Alexander Paschoaletto

Exterior Shaping: 8/15
Exterior Details: 12/15
Interior Details: 4,5/5
Engine Details: 3/5 (I agree, the engine is "horible", lol, no is not, is just not realistic! ; ) )
Functions: 10/10 (All these details!!! Wow! just wow!! ; ) )

Total: 37,5/50


Military Half Track with Power Functions by: Karol J

Exterior Shaping: 10/15
Exterior Details: 12/15
Interior Details: 4/5
Engine Details: 0/5 (there is no pics, and/or no videos of it)
Functions: 7/10

Total: 33/50
Permalink
| June 29, 2013, 10:09 am
 Group moderator 
sorry I cant judge this one because im going to be working a lot this month.=(
Permalink
| June 30, 2013, 7:36 pm
 Group admin 
Quoting hank erchief
sorry I cant judge this one because im going to be working a lot this month.=(

Okay, no problem! sadly sometimes work or school gets in the way :/
Permalink
| June 30, 2013, 7:38 pm
 Group admin 
Senator Chincilla's Toyota FJ40

Exterior Shaping: 14/15
Exterior Details: 15/15
Interior Details: 2/5
Engine Details: 0/5
Functions: 10/10

Total: 41/50
-----
Hank Erchief's 1983 K5 Blazer

Exterior Shaping: 10/15
Exterior Details: 12/15
Interior Details: 1.5/5
Engine Details: 4.5/5
Functions: 2/10

Total: 30/50

Notes: You've got some interesting details here. The real truck is rather boxy, so you got a good score on shaping easily ;) though there are some parts that could be a little more round, if you have, or can get at some point, some of these: http://www.bricklink.com/catalogItem.asp?P=2436 and these: http://www.bricklink.com/catalogItem.asp?P=54200 and use them under the door area, it adds a nice look to it :-)
Functions seeming only to be suspension and a 'working' gear shift, lowers your function score quite a bit. if you have any hinges you can add opening doors and stuff, which shouldn't be too difficult.
-----
Alex B's Off Roader of The future

Exterior details: 23/25
Exterior Shaping: 21/25
+1 for suspension
Total: 45/50

Notes: This MOC really impresses me for the scale, with some genius part usage! Though some sloping down at the back of the windscreen could up the shaping points.
-----
Alexander Paschoaletto's Subaru Impreza WRX STI

Exterior Shaping: 12/15
Exterior Details: 14/15
Interior Details: 3/5
Engine Details: 2/5
Functions: 9.5/10

Total: 40.5/50

Notes: (A very well done MOC with many details, though I would like to see a half stud ofset for the wheel arches, like on this MOC http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3593/3476482520_5ec1fc405c.jpg?v=0)
-----
Karol J's Military Half Track W/ power functions

Exterior Shaping: 14/15
Exterior Details: 15/15
Interior Details: 4/5
Engine Details: 0/5
Functions: 10/10

Total: 43/50

Notes: Clever usage of the Batter box, sadly it took the room for the engine, so i couldn't give you points for that :-(
-----
DONE

Permalink
| June 30, 2013, 8:09 pm
 Group moderator 
Alex B's Off Roader of The future:

Exterior details: 25/25
Exterior Shaping: 15/25

Total: 40/50


Hank Erchief's 1983 K5 Blazer:

Exterior Shaping: 5/15
Exterior Details: 8/15
Interior Details: 4/5
Engine Details: 5/5
Functions: 7/10

Total: 29/50
Permalink
| July 1, 2013, 9:50 am
 Group moderator 
Senator Chincilla's Toyota FJ40:

Exterior Shaping: 14/15
Exterior Details: 15/15
Interior Details: 4/5
Engine Details: 3/5
Functions: 10/10

Total: 46/50

Although there isn't any engine image, I've given 3/5 because he says it has 4 inline engine.
Permalink
| July 1, 2013, 9:58 am
 Group moderator 
Alexander Paschoaletto's Subaru Impreza WRX STI:

Exterior Shaping: 13/15
Exterior Details: 14/15
Interior Details: 5/5
Engine Details: 4/5
Functions: 6/10

Total: 42/50
Permalink
| July 1, 2013, 10:02 am
 Group moderator 
Karol J's Military Half Track W/ power functions:

Exterior Shaping: 14/15
Exterior Details: 13/15
Interior Details: 4/5
Engine Details: 3/5
Functions: 9/10

Total: 43/50

Although it doesn't have engine, I consider that it has because the Batery box is heavy and the vehicle is driveable. Because of that I give it a 3/5.
Permalink
| July 1, 2013, 10:12 am
 Group moderator 
Alex B.'s Off Roader of the Future!

Exterior Shaping: 23/25
Exterior Details: 22/25

Total: 45/50

I do love the photos and its pretty cool!

hank erchief's 1983 k5 blazer

Exterior Shaping: 8/15
Exterior Details: 9/15
Interior Details: 3/5
Engine Details: 3/5
Functions: 3/10

Total: 26/50

a nice truck! I like the lights!

Senator Chinchilla .'s Toyota Fj40 Trial Truck

Exterior Shaping: 14/15
Exterior Details: 11/15
Interior Details: 4/5
Engine Details: 4/5
Functions: 5/10

Total: 38/50

awesome!! it was very cool!

Karol J's Military Half Track with Power Functions

Exterior Shaping: 9/15
Exterior Details: 11/15
Interior Details: 4/5
Engine Details: 3/5
Functions: 9/10

Total: 36/50

awesome!! it was cool!



Permalink
| July 1, 2013, 1:47 pm
 Group admin 
Quoting Nick white
Alex B.'s Off Roader of the Future!

Exterior Shaping: 10/15
Exterior Details: 9/15
Interior Details: 1/5
Engine Details: 1/5
Functions: 5/10

Total: 26/50


Can you redo Alex's it says up there for MOCs under 6 wide to use different criteria, as interior, detail and functions easy to do at the scale.
Permalink
| July 1, 2013, 2:02 pm
 Group moderator 
Quoting TheLegoNoitAll .
Can you redo Alex's it says up there for MOCs under 6 wide to use different criteria, as interior, detail and functions easy to do at the scale.
Oh of course I will! :)
Permalink
| July 1, 2013, 3:58 pm
Quoting Hot Rod
Toyota Fj40 Trial Truck by: Senator Chinchilla

Exterior Shaping: 13/15
Exterior Details: 12/15
Interior Details: 2,5/5
Engine Details: 0/5 (there is no pics, and/or no videos of it)
Functions: 7/10

Total: 34,5/50


1983 k5 blazer by: hank erchief

Exterior Shaping: 7/15
Exterior Details: 6/15
Interior Details: 3/5
Engine Details: 3,5/5
Functions: 4/10 (I really like the suspention, but there is nothing else... :/ no openable doors, truck bed, ect)

Total: 23,5/50


Off Roader of the Future! by: Alex B

Exterior Shaping: 22/25
Exterior Details: 21/25 (a rear bumper could be a + I think! ; ) And, btw, why handcuffs under the truck? )
+1 for the suspention!

Total: 44/50

Note: I propose TLNA to "disperse" 'Interior Details', and 'Engine détails' judging points in others categories for "too small" creations! ; ), what do think about that? : )
ps: it's not what've done, yet! ; ) )


2007 Subaru Impreza WRX STI by: Alexander Paschoaletto

Exterior Shaping: 8/15
Exterior Details: 12/15
Interior Details: 4,5/5
Engine Details: 3/5 (I agree, the engine is "horible", lol, no is not, is just not realistic! ; ) )
Functions: 10/10 (All these details!!! Wow! just wow!! ; ) )

Total: 37,5/50


Military Half Track with Power Functions by: Karol J

Exterior Shaping: 10/15
Exterior Details: 12/15
Interior Details: 4/5
Engine Details: 0/5 (there is no pics, and/or no videos of it)
Functions: 7/10

Total: 33/50

I needed something to fill that space, and I thought it looked good. :)
Permalink
| July 1, 2013, 4:08 pm
 Group admin 
Quoting Nick white
Quoting TheLegoNoitAll .
Can you redo Alex's it says up there for MOCs under 6 wide to use different criteria, as interior, detail and functions easy to do at the scale.
Oh of course I will! :)

Thanks! :)
Permalink
| July 1, 2013, 4:16 pm
Can I ask Alex B why hasn't him done a 14 wide car, instead of a 4 wide, if he knew that interior and engine details would be judged? We know that he can do awesome cars from his Vortex Motors company :D
Permalink
| July 1, 2013, 9:04 pm
Quoting Nick white
Alex B.'s Off Roader of the Future!

Exterior Shaping: 11/15
Exterior Details: 11/15
Interior Details: 1/5
Engine Details: 2/5
Functions: 6/10

Total: 26/50

I do love the photos and its pretty cool!

hank erchief's 1983 k5 blazer

Exterior Shaping: 8/15
Exterior Details: 9/15
Interior Details: 3/5
Engine Details: 3/5
Functions: 3/10

Total: 26/50

a nice truck! I like the lights!

Senator Chinchilla .'s Toyota Fj40 Trial Truck

Exterior Shaping: 14/15
Exterior Details: 11/15
Interior Details: 4/5
Engine Details: 4/5
Functions: 5/10

Total: 38/50

awesome!! it was very cool!

Karol J's Military Half Track with Power Functions

Exterior Shaping: 9/15
Exterior Details: 11/15
Interior Details: 4/5
Engine Details: 3/5
Functions: 9/10

Total: 36/50

awesome!! it was cool!



what about my STI?
Permalink
| July 1, 2013, 9:06 pm
 Group moderator 
Quoting Alexander Paschoaletto
what about my STI?
Oh I'm sorry but I didn't think it was off road
Permalink
| July 1, 2013, 9:44 pm
 Group admin 
Quoting Alexander Paschoaletto
Can I ask Alex B why hasn't him done a 14 wide car, instead of a 4 wide, if he knew that interior and engine details would be judged? We know that he can do awesome cars from his Vortex Motors company :D

He was working on a larger car, but he had to wait for bricklink orders for the last parts, and he didn't have enough time to wait for them, so he built a smaller one.
Permalink
| July 2, 2013, 8:02 am
Quoting Alexander Paschoaletto
Can I ask Alex B why hasn't him done a 14 wide car, instead of a 4 wide, if he knew that interior and engine details would be judged? We know that he can do awesome cars from his Vortex Motors company :D

Yes, I planned to have a car large car finished for this, but I couldn't finish it in time because, I needed parts, and still do, but know I am out of money, so it'll take even longer to order more parts which I have to save up for. And I just liked the 4 wide scale. :)
Permalink
| July 2, 2013, 8:52 am
Quoting Nick white
Quoting Alexander Paschoaletto
what about my STI?
Oh I'm sorry but I didn't think it was off road

Of course it is! Subaru has won WRC for 3 years, awarding at all 6 trophies!

Quoting Alex B: Oh, It's a shame your bricks aren't with youyet. I can't wait to see more Vortex Cars!
Permalink
| July 2, 2013, 9:25 am
Quoting Alexander Paschoaletto
Of course it is! Subaru has won WRC for 3 years, awarding at all 6 trophies!

Quoting Alex B: Oh, It's a shame your bricks aren't with youyet. I can't wait to see more Vortex Cars!

Well, it isn't a Vortex car I need parts for, it's a yellow Jeepster. And I am going to start a new vortex car today! :) It's going to be a compact car, and It'll have a special feature, look out for it on the 4th of July! :-)
Permalink
| July 2, 2013, 9:31 am
 Group moderator 
Quoting Alexander Paschoaletto
Of course it is! Subaru has won WRC for 3 years, awarding at all 6 trophies!

Quoting Alex B: Oh, It's a shame your bricks aren't with youyet. I can't wait to see more Vortex Cars!
I'm sorry I didn't know it was for this contest of course I will judge it. :) it was an awesome car!
Permalink
| July 2, 2013, 10:30 am
 Group moderator 
Alexander Paschoaletto's
2007 Subaru Impreza WRX STI

Exterior Shaping: 13/15
Exterior Details: 12/15
Interior Details: 5/5
Engine Details: 4/5
Functions: 9/10

Total: 42/50

an awesome car!
Permalink
| July 2, 2013, 10:35 am
Can't wait to check Alex's jeepster! I am also drawing my new Tonagari. After the sketch, I'll make it in Lego :D
Permalink
| July 2, 2013, 4:58 pm
 Group moderator 
Quoting Alex B
but I did judge your off roader! :)

Permalink
| July 2, 2013, 5:40 pm
Quoting Nick white
Quoting Alex B
but I did judge your off roader! :)

I know you did, but by the wrong rules. The lego no it all has certain ways to judge a car under 6 wide. Look at his original post. :)
Permalink
| July 2, 2013, 6:37 pm
 Group moderator 
Quoting Alex B
I know you did, but by the wrong rules. The lego no it all has certain ways to judge a car under 6 wide. Look at his original post. :)
ooooh I didn't see that sorry well I fixed it :)
Permalink
| July 2, 2013, 9:23 pm
Quoting Nick white
Quoting Alex B
I know you did, but by the wrong rules. The lego no it all has certain ways to judge a car under 6 wide. Look at his original post. :)
ooooh I didn't see that sorry well I fixed it :)

Thank you very much! :-)
Permalink
| July 3, 2013, 8:05 am
 Group moderator 
Senator Chinchilla's Toyota
Exterior Shaping: 14/15
Exterior Details: 10/15
Interior Details: 4/5
Engine Details: 4/5
Functions: 9/10
Overall: 41/50

Hank Erchief's K5 Blazer
Exterior Shaping: 12/15
Exterior Details: 12/15
Interior Details: 3/5
Engine Details: 4/5
Functions: 8/10
Overall: 39/50

Alex B's Off Roader of the Future
Exterior details: 20/25
Exterior Shaping: 22/25
Overall: 42/50

Alexander Pashoaletto's Subaru Impreza
Exterior Shaping: 12/15
Exterior Details: 13/15
Interior Details: 3/5
Engine Details: 2/5
Functions: 8/10
overall: 38/50

Karol J's Military half track
Exterior Shaping: 13/15
Exterior Details: 13/15
Interior Details: 4/5
Engine Details: 2/5
Functions: 8/10
overall: 40/50

Permalink
| July 4, 2013, 11:55 am
Quoting Alexander Paschoaletto
Can't wait to check Alex's jeepster! I am also drawing my new Tonagari. After the sketch, I'll make it in Lego :D
It'll be a little while before that's done. :( But I have a new Vortex Motors Car! =) I am going to try to post it tomorrow. I can't wait to see your car! =]

Permalink
| July 4, 2013, 11:57 am
Quoting Harry Gravett
Senator Chinchilla's Toyota
Exterior Shaping: 14/15
Exterior Details: 10/15
Interior Details: 4/5
Engine Details: 4/5
Functions: 9/10
Overall: 41/50

Hank Erchief's K5 Blazer
Exterior Shaping: 12/15
Exterior Details: 12/15
Interior Details: 3/5
Engine Details: 4/5
Functions: 8/10
Overall: 39/50

Alex B's Off Roader of the Future
Exterior Shaping: 9/15
Exterior Details: 8/15
Interior Details: 2/5
Engine Details: 2/5
Functions: 1/10
Overall: 22/50

Alexander Pashoaletto's Subaru Impreza
Exterior Shaping: 12/15
Exterior Details: 13/15
Interior Details: 3/5
Engine Details: 2/5
Functions: 8/10
overall: 38/50

Karol J's Military half track
Exterior Shaping: 13/15
Exterior Details: 13/15
Interior Details: 4/5
Engine Details: 2/5
Functions: 8/10
overall: 40/50

Hello Harry! On my entry, look at the Lego No it All's original post, you score cars under 6 wide differently. Just so you know. :)
Permalink
| July 5, 2013, 7:17 am
Other topics
« Contest 2 Judging
student teen kid toy play lego child video game hobby blocks construction toy legos fun games



LEGO models my own creation MOCpages toys shop The Car Builder's Club: contest groupVehicles


You Your home page | LEGO creations | Favorite builders
Activity Activity | Comments | Creations
Explore Explore | Recent | Groups
MOCpages is an unofficial, fan-created website. LEGO® and the brick configuration are property of The LEGO Group, which does not sponsor, own, or endorse this site.
©2002-2014 Sean Kenney Design Inc | Privacy policy | Terms of use