Hi there, my name is Skarmory. I'm on MoC as a commentator really, as the place I live in doesn't lend itself to affordably acquiring large ammounts of Lego blocks. I may submit a small thing now and then, but don't count on it.
Speaking of which, I use a slightly unusual scale:
5 - Excellent - Jaw drops, eyes refuse to blink, mind goes into a loop. This is the reaction to truly brilliant MoCs. Well thought out, well designed, well fluffed and well constructed. If you get here, be proud. Be very proud.
4 - Very Good - Altough truly a good MoC, it's a step or several from being best. Basically replace the and from above with and/or and there you have it.
3 - Good - There's nothing wrong about this MoC. It's not brilliant, but it's a solid piece of work. In Warhammer we call it 'Tabletop Quality' - models we aren't ashamed to bring out, and get the odd praise from one who doesn't know zing about how the good look like.
2 - Average - Just what it says - this MoC is average - not downright bad, but not great either. Usually it lacks in one of the four major categories, while being roughly decent in the rest.
1 - Poor - There is something wrong with the MoC. The design is crap, the colors are completely wrong, the fluff is nonsense (even worse than inexistant), or it's Über, IE. described as not having any weaknesses. Long story short, I don't like it, ven though others may.