My personal favourites are the Comedian, Ozymandias and Nite Owl II, though the latter's helmet could use some reduction of the horns, you know, to resemble the head of an owl more accurately. Leaving that finickiness aside, the fact that these custom figs are quite puristic makes them definitely worth 5/5.
those are all pretty sweet especially Manhattan. how did you make those? are they decals? i made some decals for them. they can be found at the bottom of this page: http://www.mocpages.com/moc.php/88689
could you just tell me how you like them?
The only change I would suggest is Rorshach's face. He looks too much like the Golden Age version of Sandman. Now that you've made these maybe you could do Minutemen, the other superhero team from the Watchmen story. I would love to see your version of Silk Spectre I, Nite Owl I, Silhouette, Hooded Justice, Captain Metropolis, Dollar Bill, young Comedian, and Mothman