Pretty nice execution, though I would like to see more rubble, on the streets and in heaps. I'm also questioning the hobbit designs. Still, the scenery said 'Osgiliath' to me before I even saw the full image. Very nice.
nice ruins. i really didn't like that scene. the knights of gondor were so stupid. they knew the orcs were coming and then they let the orcs land and waited for half the army to get past before leaping out and attacking the middle of the orc horde. because of that stupid idea they were surrounded by orcs right from the begining, when they could have just shot some fire arrows into the boats when the orcs were in the middle of the river, or just plain old arrows if they didn't have fire. it bothers me every time that the awesome warriors of gondor would do something so dumb.
anyway, great moc, the ruins are the best part!