Accuracy to book 30/35. Originality 23/25. Creativity/technique 23/30, The rocks are a bit to block like and too similar to one another. Also the trees could use some work. Minifigs 6/10, some of the dwarves don't look a lot like dwarves. Total 82/100, Thanks for making an entry!
accuracy to the book: 30/35 ; originality: 17/25 creativity/technique: 27/30 (a little bit blocky, but nice details!); minifigs: 5/10. I think they could be more detailed. Total: 79/100