These are my results for the second Mecha Contests contest. Credit for the picture goes to Thomas Z., winner of the last contest.
About this creation
RAS-12 "JackRabbit" - RabidGoldfish
Basic Design: 4/5 I really liked how this mech looked, however I felt the arms were just too simply, and didn't look very nice in contrast to the rest of the mech.
Flow: 4/5 Again, it all flows very nicely until you hit the arms - they could have done with some extra, smooth plating.
Aerodynamics: 4/5 Quite nice, but again the arms let it down in this region.
Originality: 3.5/5 Quite original, but not really out there. It's sort of what you would expect, but it still gets a nice mark from me.
Coolness: 5/5 A very cool mecha, depsite its little losses. I absolutely loved the wheel feet.
Overall: 20.5/25 A very nice score indeed, great work.
Team GB "RoadRunner" - androstempest
Basic Design: 4/5 While I found that its lack of arms and thin legs let it down, its transforming function more than made up for it.
Flow: 3/5 While both modes look quite nice, I did not feel like that flowed very well - lack of arms didn't help.
Aerodynamics: 5/5 What more needs to be said?
Originality 5/5 Very nice, off the wall yet still what you want to see.
Coolness: 4/5 The head and its transformation were excellent, however I felt that its legs were just a tad too spindly.
Overall: 21/25 Another excellent creation andros, good job.
RMX-8 - aaron yates
Basic Design: 4/5 While it was a bit bulky, I found it to be very pleasing in design.
Flow: 4/5 It is rather bulky, however I felt the bulkiness was quite weel handled for a racer mech.
Aerodynamics: 3/5 Its bulkiness however let it down in this catagory, could have done with a bit more curvature.
Originality: 3.5 Much like Rabid's, it's quite original, but not hugely so.
Coolness: 4.5/5 To be, it was an awesome mech, with a sweet leg design.
Overall: 20/25 A very nice mech, with a bit of work it could well have achieved full marks.
"Bagheera" - Chris D.
I'm gonna leave the commentation 'till the end for this one.
Basic Design: 5/5
Overall score: 25/25 Well done, good sir. I could find no fault with your piece of excellance, gaining you a perfect score and my vote for winner.
CG-2 "Lancelot Blitz" GT - Thomas Z.
Basic Design: 4/5 A very nice build, until you reach the feet . . .
Flow: 4/5 Beautifully done body, horrible feet I'm afraid.
Aerodynamics: 4.5/5 It's body and even the front of its feet are however beautifully aerodynamic, so a bit higher score here.
Originality: 3.5/5 Same reasons as aaron and Rabid, not the most orignal but still quite nice for it.
Coolness 3.5/5 It was so cool when I first saw it, however I am afraid I really disliked your feet design, and I'm afraid that lost you a fair few marks here =(
Overall score: 19.5/25 A very nice entry, but for me the feet were a massive let down - those wheels just simply did not work.
Tempest Racer Mech Mk.I - ariklego
Basic Design: 4/5 A very nice design, loving it, but a bit chunky for my liking.
Flow: 4/5 Quite a nice flow, but again quite chunky in the running.
Aerodynamics: 4/5 A nice bit of aerodynamics, plenty of curves etc.
Originality: 3.5/5 Same reasons as Thomas, aaron and Rabid, quite original but not super daring.
Coolness: 4/5 Very cool indeed, but could be even better.
Overall score: 18.5/25 The added up marks of the others are 19.5/25, however as you did go over the height limit I have deducted 1 point from your score.